Wednesday, June 9, 2010

India's secularism- part 1

Indian 'Secularism' as I came to know it


Indians are generally ignorant about their Constitution because the government has no initiative to educate them about it. I never have seen a copy of it, only an e-version after the advent of inter-net. But I do have a free copy of the constitution of my domicile country- South Africa . The majority of Indians who do not have access to the inter-net have no chance to see even the e-version of it.

However, referring to constitutional clauses without knowing what they really entail has become second nature to us. For example a discussion about religion and related matters does not end without defining secularism and often these definitions are misleading and confusing.

It is in this context that I wanted to study secularism in the context of Indian constitution as well as how it was practiced in traditional India?

Secularism since independence

Indian Constitution "did not contain the word 'secular' except incidentally in Article 25 (2)(b)". It was in 1976, twenty six years after India became a constitutional democracy in 1950 that secularism was added to it
by the 42nd amendment, that too by the autocrat of the Nehru dynasty Mrs I. Gandhi.
The amendment clause is as follows:

"Proposed to amend the Constitution to spell out expressly the high ideals of socialism, secularism and the integrity of the directive principles more comprehensive and give them precedence over those fundamental rights, which have been allowed to be relied upon to frustrate socioeconomic reforms for implementing the directive principles. It is also proposed to specify the fundamental duties of the citizens and make special provisions for dealing with anti-national activities,whether by individuals or associations."

The amendment does not define what secularism is. Given the parliamentary terrorism introduced by Mrs. Gandhi into Indian democracy under National Emergency she declared the year before and the suppression of civil liberty and press freedom followed thereafter, I really wonder what was her intension behind the amendment.

Secularism means separation between State and religion, that is total non-interference of one from the other.

From the wording, it appears the Amendment did not mean to spell out anything new about secularism but only to 'spell out expressly its high ideals' already contained in our Constitution.

What were the high ideals contained in our Constitution?

In 1947, when India became independent, Sardar Patel the Deputy Prime Minister of India ' pledged that the Government of India would reconstruct the Somanath temple destroyed in 1025 AD by the Muslim invader Mohammad Gazri and the Cabinet presided over by Jawaharlal Nehru agreed that the government would bear the full cost of it. Gandhiji opposed the plan suggesting the money for Somanath reconstruction be collected from the people for it was a Hindu religious issue and his wish was respected.

K.M.Munshi was the chairman of the committee for reconstructing the temple. After the installation of the temple on May 11, 1951, according to Munshi J. Nehru chided him for his involvement in the temple construction, 'I don't like you(r) trying to restore Somanath. It is Hindu revivalism'.

The change in Nehru could be attributed to the 'secular' ideals included in the Indian Constitution passed in 1950. Means Indian secularism stood for the separation of State from the religions. But it was not expressed openly. And WHY?

Has India got a secular legacy?

There is an argument going that secularism is a western idea and that it has no relevance to India. So it entails to look at whether secularism has any relevance to India.
Secularism means separation of State from religion. Religion here means institutionalized religion not personal religion.
In traditional India, as far as I know, there was no trace of institutionalized religions.  Remnants of Indus valley civilization show no trace of religion as a social institution. The moral life of the period was based on a cause and effect spirituality or a search into one's own existence or to the Self. Whether god (no deities) was central to it or not the search was intuitive and rational. Individuals enjoyed their freedom to pursue any philosophy in search of his or spirituality which had nothing to do with the State and its governing. So in traditional India, spirituality was an individual experience and hence State was separated from religion.


So my point is that secularism is not a foreign or a western idea to  India.
Contrary to the past, when we come to the contemporary religions like Hinduism, Christianity and Islam they are institutionalized religions; their canons and practices are centrally controlled by gods or similar powers in the heavens in whose desire are sent down messiahs or prophets who designed the dogmas and traditions the believers are supposed to follow. Ultimate purpose of those religions is to attain salvation -heaven- through conformity with the dogmas and the fear of hell, in the after life and not through a cause and effect spirituality, intuition or rationality which enables individuals  to take control of his or her own life choosing proven values.

Such religion institutions while posing to be seats of god and spirituality ironically enjoy power and prowess through numbers-followers. Politics is another institution that enjoys power through numbers. So the making and the function of these two institutions itself warrant an unholy affiliation between the two. Religion being a crowd puller on its potential to create a sense of collective identity or consciousness among individuals and politics an institution preying on collective identity makes this unholy affiliation a lethal threat to nation building.

Hence for India to sustain nation-building democracy it has to be secular. Religion institutions have to be steered clear of politics and vice versa.

Now coming to the post 42nd amendment era.

I had already mentioned how Mrs. Gandhi had unleashed her political terrorism under the cover of National Emergency. Given the way she and her party conducted the business of Indian democracy there after, one can say, nothing had seemingly forthcome out of her 42nd amendment tantamount to spell out secularism 'expressly'.

 
To the erstwhile dynastic and colonial elements that waited on the wings to piece India into minority and savarna cantonments, Mrs. Gandhi's autocracy, disregard to law and order, mastery in rigging parliamentary elections etc gave the best chance. To the majority who still kept the flame of old secular and humanistic ways of life at heart and passionately and passively followed the rulers, Mrs. Gandhi was a bad example. Her scant regard to modesty, morality and humanity diminished their hopes and trust in a national leader. Her selective promotion of varna Hindus and the minorities to key civilian and parliamentary positions over the majority and the intellectuals were open calls to comunalism which went against India's secular traditions. In short, instead of spelling out 'expressly' the secular ideals, Mrs. Gandhi's post 42nd amendment promoted nonsecular elements in Indian politics which would cast a permanent shadow on the sky of Indian secularism.

After Mrs. Gandhi, came other leaders from Congress and other parties. Their decision not to tamper with the nonsecular constructs of Mrs. Gandhi was unanimous because they benefited out of them. The term 'vote bank' was coined in the Indian context to mean Indian constituencies chose leaders not following their statesmanship or leadership qualities but caste, religion or varna/racial affiliation.

The post-Mrs. Gandhi chapter of India saw the worst form of vote-bank politics. The two non-congress political parties, the BJP and the Janatha Dal, entered the fray through wooing the OBCS- the indigenous people of India battered and discriminated for generations by the so called savarnas- and the premature implementation of Mandal Commission Report, Ram janmabhumi sensational drive all pieced India into further communal cantonments and finally destroyed all chance of India to be a Nation.


In conclusion

Secularism as separation between politics and institutionalized religion was enshrined in the Indian constitution. And there were Indian leaders who maintained that provision. But those ideals were not spelled out expressly in the Indian Constitution. Secularism is an Indian legacy. Modern religions are non-secular. Their communal interests are in conflict with the parliamentary democracy off the State. Indira Gandhi's 42nd amendment of the Constitution was intended to spell 'them out expressly', but her political action only plunged India into communalism and fundamentalism.


ref.
http://www.iheu.org/node/298

http://indiacode.nic.in/coiweb/welcome.html







95 comments:

  1. Indian Constitution "did not contain the word 'secular' except incidentally in Article 25 (2)(b)". It was in 1976, twenty six years after India became a constitutional democracy in 1950 that secularism was added to it by the 42nd amendment, that too by the autocrat of the Nehru dynasty Mrs I. Gandhi.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. മാഷേ,

    ഞാന്‍ അതിന്റെ മലയാളം വേര്‍ഷനും എഴുതിയിട്ടൂണ്ട്.
    ദാ ഇവിടെ

    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent write up ! Clear and concise.!

    It is debatable whether the notions of secularism a western concept or not..But what cannot be argued is the fact that is a noble ideal. So even f Indians did not have a taste of secularism it would foolish to suggest that they should continue to live with out that.

    If ,secularism is a western concept, the what about Democracy..? Since Democracy did not exist in India while it had made its presence felt in western world , why on earth we adopted it ..?

    What about western system of laws and justice..? Why we adopted if it was Western and not Indian..?

    So irrespective of whether secularism is a western concept of not it is modern concept to be adopted by the humanity seeking the path of progress.

    ReplyDelete
  5. CV,

    thanks a lot for visiting my blog and making this valuable contribution towards discussion.

    Why should we say something that is not historically right. India follows secularism in its own way. And by the way India has not followed secularism in the way the west has pronounced it. western secularism is total separation between state and religion. India is not practicing that kind of a secularism. So why should I say that India is following western secularism. This is the dilemma.

    And India follows western democracy. This is a myth. West has not invented democracy. We are taught to believe that Plato invented democracy. I also believed that until I came to know that that is not true. I have written that in my another blog. Please read here

    I have no problem is accepting a borrowing from another culture if that is the truth.

    please response

    ReplyDelete
  6. "India is not practicing that kind of a secularism. So why should I say that India is following western secularism. This is the dilemma."

    I too share that dilemma teacher. But my point is that India need to change its own concept (if there is one)of secularism and switch to the western concept of clear separation of state and religion (not only in the administration of the state but more importantly in ensuring that the existence of the modern state itself is not compromised by flowing diluted ,loosely defined idea)

    When the state find its contract with an individual is seriously scuttled by interference fro third parties, it is of paramount importance to put the foot down and act.

    My problem with the current setup is that it just let too many players interfere in the basic modern state model, jeopardizing the freedom promised to an individual by the state by means of a contract.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  10. generic xanax xanax 2mg price - best place buy xanax online

    ReplyDelete
  11. alprazolam buy xanax 3 mg pills - xanax withdrawal migraine

    ReplyDelete
  12. xanax online xanax bars for recreational use - xanax orange pill

    ReplyDelete
  13. buy tramadol online buy tramadol online florida - tramadol hcl 100mg side effects

    ReplyDelete
  14. buy tramadol online tramadol half life - order tramadol online cheap

    ReplyDelete
  15. buy tramadol online no prescription tramadol overnight delivery - tramadol addiction in egypt

    ReplyDelete
  16. carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol tablets 350mg - carisoprodol 1400 mg

    ReplyDelete
  17. order tramadol overnight buy tramadol online no prescription usa - normal dosage tramadol humans

    ReplyDelete
  18. buy tramadol online tramadol hydrochloride capsules 100 mg - tramadol overnight saturday delivery

    ReplyDelete
  19. alprazolam without prescription generic xanax vs. name brand - xanax pills and dosage

    ReplyDelete
  20. buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg and naproxen - tramadol online overnight delivery

    ReplyDelete
  21. buy tramadol without prescriptions tramadol 50 mg for cramps - tramadol ibuprofen

    ReplyDelete
  22. buy carisoprodol carisoprodol usa no prescription - carisoprodol 350 mg addictive

    ReplyDelete
  23. xanax online xanax on drug test - does 2mg generic xanax look like

    ReplyDelete
  24. buy tramadol online legal buy tramadol online usa - tramadol 50 mg kapsler

    ReplyDelete
  25. xanax 0.5mg generic xanax stamped g3721 - blue xanax pills generic

    ReplyDelete
  26. xanax online ritalin and xanax high - 2mg xanax 2 beers

    ReplyDelete
  27. buy carisoprodol carisoprodol 350 mg tablet what - carisoprodol 350 mg price

    ReplyDelete
  28. buy cialis online buy cheap cialis from us - buy cheap cialis online no prescription

    ReplyDelete
  29. xanax online xanax withdrawal symptoms in newborns - xanax buy online mastercard

    ReplyDelete
  30. cialis online cialis online drugs - cialis 5 mg buy online

    ReplyDelete
  31. buy cialis online cialis 20 mg - order cialis online australia

    ReplyDelete
  32. buy cialis online generic 36 hour cialis - buy cialis online with no prescription

    ReplyDelete
  33. xanax online no prescription xanax 0.5 effects - can mixing xanax and alcohol kill you

    ReplyDelete
  34. cialis online cialis online without rx - cialis online pharmacy us

    ReplyDelete
  35. cialis online cialis drug interactions - cheap cialis ireland

    ReplyDelete
  36. buy cialis online cialis 5mg price comparison - cialis for daily use and bph

    ReplyDelete
  37. cheap tadalafil cialis daily use reviews - generic cialis 20 mg usa

    ReplyDelete
  38. generic xanax buy xanax no prescription from canada - generic xanax strengths

    ReplyDelete
  39. cialis online cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews - cheapest cialis online usa

    ReplyDelete
  40. buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg for dogs - tramadol 100mg wirkung

    ReplyDelete
  41. 20000 :) buy celebrex without rx - purchase celebrex no prescription http://www.celebrexpharmsite.net/, [url=http://www.celebrexpharmsite.net/]celebrex cost [/url]

    ReplyDelete
  42. http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#73892 tramadol 50 mg drug interactions - buy tramadol online cod only

    ReplyDelete
  43. http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#63102 300 mg tramadol overdose - buy tramadol online overnight mastercard

    ReplyDelete
  44. buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg and aleve - tramadol tylenol

    ReplyDelete
  45. buy tramadol tablets buy tramadol online cod no prescription - tramadol 50mg side effects for dogs

    ReplyDelete
  46. buy tramadol tramadol purchase online no prescription - tramadol 50 mg cheap

    ReplyDelete
  47. http://landvoicelearning.com/#57594 tramadol high lasts - tramadol 50mg tablets vs vicodin

    ReplyDelete
  48. buy tramadol tramadol shipped with no prescription - tramadol overdose damage

    ReplyDelete
  49. http://landvoicelearning.com/#38471 tramadol 50mg or 100mg - tramadol online no prescription needed

    ReplyDelete
  50. buy tramadol online buy tramadol cheap no prescription - tramadol kidney damage

    ReplyDelete
  51. buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg many get high - cheap tramadol usa

    ReplyDelete
  52. 1, buy lasix furosemide - buy lasix without rx http://www.lasixordernow.net/, [url=http://www.lasixordernow.net/]where can i buy lasix [/url]

    ReplyDelete
  53. This implies the person cauѕeѕ it tο οccur upon
    hіmѕelf. VIAGRA takeѕ 30-60 minutes before it aсtivateѕ male orgаns and it гemаіns effеctive for аbout four hours.
    Іn the past, discussions on еrectile dysfunctiοn were ρгimarily left tο the aсаdemе and clіniсal communities due to the
    fаct indiviԁuаlѕ saω it aѕ
    taboo.

    my web blog :: effects of cialis and grapefruit

    ReplyDelete
  54. buy tramadol tramadol hcl 50 mg picture - ultram or tramadol

    ReplyDelete
  55. buy tramadol online tramadol no prescription overnight cod delivery - legal buy tramadol online us

    ReplyDelete
  56. buy tramadol tramadol online forum - tramadol hcl 50 mg snort

    ReplyDelete
  57. http://landvoicelearning.com/#57594 50mg tramadol high dose - tramadol 50mg side effects

    ReplyDelete
  58. buy tramadol overdose of tramadol hydrochloride - tramadol 50mg (generic ultram)

    ReplyDelete
  59. buy tramadol tramadol use addiction - tramadol and alcohol

    ReplyDelete
  60. buy tramadol order tramadol online us pharmacy - tramadol 50 mg for headaches

    ReplyDelete
  61. buy tramadol tramadol hcl high effects - 100 mg tramadol online

    ReplyDelete
  62. ways to buy ativan online ativan how fast does it work - ativan overdose pupils

    ReplyDelete
  63. buy xanax online order xanax online prescription - xanax withdrawal symptoms duration

    ReplyDelete
  64. http://staam.org/#37708 can you buy tramadol over counter usa - buy tramadol with visa

    ReplyDelete
  65. buy tramadol hcl order tramadol online without script - tramadol hcl 50mg 627

    ReplyDelete
  66. Me and ozzy fucked harder, trying to show to our god! FUCK YES!
    ' right before cumming inside my warm pussy. were still fucking

    Stop by my website hcg injections
    My site :: hcg injections

    ReplyDelete
  67. buy tramadol ultram tramadol 50 mg buy online - can you buy tramadol over counter usa

    ReplyDelete
  68. buy xanax online after effects xanax overdose - alprazolam 0.5 mg picture

    ReplyDelete
  69. buy xanax online xanax side effects heart palpitations - order xanax online cheap

    ReplyDelete
  70. buy xanax online xanax and alcohol consumption - xanax benadryl drug interactions

    ReplyDelete
  71. buy xanax bars online no prescription xanax drug of choice - xanax dosage 0.5

    ReplyDelete
  72. Hola! I've been reading your blog for a long time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Kingwood Tx! Just wanted to say keep up the good work!

    My blog post; オークリー アウトレット

    ReplyDelete
  73. Very great post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to
    say that I have truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
    In any case I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I'm hoping you write once more very soon!

    my blog; レイバンサングラス

    ReplyDelete
  74. Very great post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I have truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
    In any case I will be subscribing to your rss feed
    and I'm hoping you write once more very soon!

    Stop by my blog post ... レイバンサングラス

    ReplyDelete
  75. Wonderful post however I was wanting to know if you could write a
    litte more on this subject? I'd be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Many thanks!

    My blog post - オークリー ゴーグル

    ReplyDelete
  76. I all the time emailed this webpage post page to all my friends, since if like to read it then my links will too.


    Here is my webpage; http://www.oakleyfreeshipping.com

    ReplyDelete
  77. Thanks for every other informative blog.
    Where else may just I get that kind of info written in such a perfect means?
    I have a challenge that I am just now operating on,
    and I've been at the look out for such info.

    my web-site オークリーメガネ

    ReplyDelete
  78. Hello there! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers?
    I'm kinda paranoid about losing everything I've worked hard
    on. Any suggestions?

    My web blog ... http://www.oakleyxxx.com/

    ReplyDelete
  79. Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your website
    and in accession capital to assert that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts.
    Any way I'll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

    my webpage - www.timvasko.com

    ReplyDelete
  80. What's up to every , for the reason that I am really eager of reading this weblog's post
    to be updated on a regular basis. It carries pleasant data.



    my web site: オークリー 店舗

    ReplyDelete
  81. Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The
    text in your content seem to be running off the screen in Firefox.
    I'm not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with internet browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know.
    The design and style look great though! Hope you
    get the issue fixed soon. Thanks

    Feel free to surf to my weblog ... 2013raybanfreeshipping.com

    ReplyDelete
  82. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  83. Hey there! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community
    in the same niche. Your blog provided us beneficial information to work on.
    You have done a outstanding job!

    Here is my web blog ... レイバンサングラス

    ReplyDelete
  84. Hеre too In thаt геspесt levels to Run through аnԁ through,
    wіth each gettіng moгe haгd anԁ exсiting.
    Thеԁragonflу aіrstгeam gameis a subspeсіes robots аnd pіle up the flake!
    Α few wrangle regarԁing site is an іncгedible геѕоurce.
    Ι Rеckon On thаt poіnt
    a plenіtude of wаgеrer sеlection about but іf you Desire to go tells you hoω many fіsh to Taκe hοld of and alѕо diѕplays the rοutine in Orangеnеsѕ.
    Τhese interaсtionѕ may be plаyed Eithеr aѕ from the Pгince Caspian mоνing pіctuгe.


    Ηere is my hοmepаgе - game

    ReplyDelete
  85. Outstanding story there. What happened after?
    Take care!

    Here is my web site ... Costs Of Dental Implants

    ReplyDelete
  86. Awesomе blog! Do you have аnу rеcommendationѕ for aspiгіng writers?

    I'm planning to start my own blog soon but I'm a littlе lost
    on everything. Would you ѕuggest startіng with a free ρlatform like Wordpress or go for a paid oрtіοn?
    Тhеre aгe ѕo manу оptions
    οut there that I'm totally overwhelmed .. Any tips? Bless you!

    My site - hcg diet food list

    ReplyDelete
  87. generic tramadol buy tramadol overnight shipping - cheap tramadolonline

    ReplyDelete
  88. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  89. Buy Tramadol Online tramadol buy - buy tramadol medication

    ReplyDelete
  90. I've been browsing online more than 2 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all website owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the internet will be much more useful than ever before.

    Feel free to visit my blog post - cellulite treatment

    ReplyDelete
  91. Artiсle ωriting is аlso a fun, if you
    be aсquainted with after that you can wrіte oг еlѕe it іs complicated
    to ωrite.

    Fеel fгеe to surf tо my websіte ...
    forex currency prices

    ReplyDelete